Companies A-Z Rankings Categories Problems By state Latest complaints Trends Compare Experiences Reports Guides Share your experience
Theme

Auto loans & leases

CarMax auto loans & leases complaints

Consumers have filed 1,317 complaints about CarMax's auto loans & leases, 314 in the last 12 months (+15%). CarMax answered 99.4% on time and closed 1% with relief. See the whole CarMax record.

CarMax against other auto lenders

#Company12 monthsChangeOn timeReliefAll time
1Santander Holdings USA2,463+55%100%36%5,915
2Ally Financial1,987+53%100%4%9,980
3Westlake Financial1,921+69%100%0%6,159
4Credit Acceptance1,277+12%99.7%4%6,077
5Capital One1,226+18%100%2%6,197
6Bridgecrest1,019+29%99.5%0%3,330
7Hyundai Capital America996+81%100%0%4,690
8Toyota Financial Services938+52%99.9%6%4,524
9Exeter Finance830+24%99.9%0%2,969
10Wells Fargo686+40%100%19%6,683
11American Honda Finance556+57%99.6%0%2,789
12American Credit Acceptance554+63%100%0%1,840
13CarMax314+15%99.4%1%1,317

Every auto lender ranked

Latest CarMax auto loans & leases complaints

ReceivedAboutIssueStateAnswerOn time
Dec 23, 2025Auto loans & leasesRepossessionLoan balance remaining after the vehicle is repossessed and soldDEExplainedYes
Dec 22, 2025Auto loans & leasesManaging the loan or leaseProblem with additional products or services purchased with the loanILExplainedYes
Dec 22, 2025Auto loans & leasesStruggling to pay your loanDenied request to lower paymentsINFixedYes
Dec 20, 2025Auto loans & leasesRepossessionLender trying to repossess or disable the vehicleFLExplainedYes
Dec 19, 2025Auto loans & leasesRepossessionLoan balance remaining after the vehicle is repossessed and soldCAExplainedYes
Dec 19, 2025Auto loans & leasesRepossessionLoan balance remaining after the vehicle is repossessed and soldGAExplainedYes
Dec 19, 2025Auto loans & leasesIncorrect information on your reportAccount information incorrectWIExplainedYes
Dec 18, 2025Auto loans & leasesIncorrect information on your reportInformation belongs to someone elseGAExplainedYes
Dec 18, 2025Auto loans & leasesRepossessionDamage caused or loss of personal items in vehicle during the actual repossessionWAExplainedYes
Dec 17, 2025Auto loans & leasesManaging the loan or leaseBilling problemNHExplainedYes
Dec 16, 2025Auto loans & leasesProblems at the end of the loan or leaseUnable to receive car title or other problem after the loan is paid offGAExplainedYes
Dec 16, 2025Auto loans & leasesManaging the loan or leaseBilling problemGAExplainedYes
Dec 15, 2025Auto loans & leasesGetting a loan or leaseCredit denialUTExplainedYes
Dec 15, 2025Auto loans & leasesIncorrect information on your reportAccount status incorrectGAExplainedYes
Dec 15, 2025Auto loans & leasesProblem with a company's investigation into an existing problemTheir investigation did not fix an error on your reportCAExplainedYes
Dec 14, 2025Auto loans & leasesManaging the loan or leaseProblem with fees chargedMSExplainedYes
Dec 14, 2025Auto loans & leasesProblem with a company's investigation into an existing problemTheir investigation did not fix an error on your reportILExplainedYes
Dec 11, 2025Auto loans & leasesRepossessionDamage caused or loss of personal items in vehicle during the actual repossessionGAExplainedYes
Dec 10, 2025Auto loans & leasesGetting a loan or leaseLoan opened without my consent or knowledgeNCExplainedYes
Dec 9, 2025Auto loans & leasesRepossessionLoan balance remaining after the vehicle is repossessed and soldMDExplainedYes
Dec 6, 2025Auto loans & leasesManaging the loan or leaseProblem with the interest rateALExplainedYes
Dec 5, 2025Auto loans & leasesProblems at the end of the loan or leaseUnable to receive car title or other problem after the loan is paid offMOExplainedYes
Dec 5, 2025Auto loans & leasesProblem with a company's investigation into an existing problemTheir investigation did not fix an error on your reportMAExplainedYes
Dec 4, 2025Auto loans & leasesProblems at the end of the loan or leaseProblem while selling or giving up the vehicleFLExplainedYes
Dec 3, 2025Auto loans & leasesIncorrect information on your reportInformation belongs to someone elseFLExplainedYes
Dec 3, 2025Auto loans & leasesRepossessionCompany communicating payment assistance or payment extension optionsINExplainedYes
Dec 3, 2025Auto loans & leasesManaging the loan or leaseProblem with the interest rateGAExplainedYes
Nov 30, 2025Auto loans & leasesProblem with a company's investigation into an existing problemTheir investigation did not fix an error on your reportNYExplainedYes
Nov 29, 2025Auto loans & leasesRepossessionDeficiency balance after repossessionGAExplainedYes
Nov 27, 2025Auto loans & leasesIncorrect information on your reportAccount information incorrectGAFixedYes

Your rights with auto lenders

Repossession rules come from your contract and your state's law: in many states a lender can repossess without warning once you default, but it cannot breach the peace, and it must tell you how to get the car back and how it will be sold. You are usually entitled to a refund of unused add-ons such as GAP or service contracts when the loan ends early.

Scam warning: Watch for add-ons slipped into the contract, and get every promise in writing before you sign. A dealer cannot make you buy extras to get the loan.

General information, not legal advice; rules vary by state. Plain-English guides

Talk about CarMax

Be kind and stick to facts. No account numbers or other people's details. Rules

No comments yet. Start the conversation - questions are welcome too.

Complaint records are public consumer complaints filed with U.S. regulators, checked (newest received Nov 15, 2026). Complaints are consumers' own accounts and are not verified; counts grow with a company's size. How the data works

Check the record before you sign.

Then add to it. Every experience you share - good or bad - goes on that company's record and helps the next person decide. Two minutes, anonymous.

Share your experience